Show summary Hide summary
When Black Sabbath reunited with Ozzy Osbourne in 2001, fans hoped new music would follow. Instead, a set of sessions with producer Rick Rubin was abandoned. Bassist Geezer Butler recently explained why the project never reached stores, and why a song fans remember from Ozzfest never became an official release.
Why the 2001 sessions were halted
The band regrouped and wrote new material after their reunion. They even played one of the new songs live. But the studio work did not go as planned.
Nas slams music industry over disrespect: teases new music, vows to address it
1992 vocal performances: 3 jaw-dropping moments that still amaze
- Meetings with Rick Rubin led to a reality check.
- The group played several finished tracks for him.
- Hearing the songs to an outsider made the band rethink everything.
Butler said the moment they played the material for Rubin was decisive. The band concluded the songs were not good enough. They felt the music sounded forced, and they stopped work on the project.
The tale of “Scary Dreams” and its live debut
“Scary Dreams” is the one tune many fans remember from that era. Black Sabbath performed it at Ozzfest in 2001 after their reunion with Ozzy. Despite the live appearance, the song never reached an official release.
“Scary Dreams” technically remains unreleased. For many listeners, the Ozzfest performance is the only glimpse of that period’s material.
Fan expectations and the reality
- Hearing a new song live raised hopes for a full record.
- The band later judged the tracks as substandard.
- What sounded promising on stage did not survive the studio review.
What Geezer Butler revealed on the podcast
Butler discussed the abandoned sessions on his wife Gloria Butler’s podcast, Gabbing With Girlfriends. He gave a candid account of the band’s feelings about the songs.
- They had roughly eight new compositions.
- About six of those were completed in the studio.
- Most of the work took place in Monmouth, Wales.
According to Butler, once they played the material for someone outside the group, they realized it wasn’t right. He admitted he disliked the songs and that they felt forced. That realization led them to abandon the project rather than release work they did not believe in.
Rick Rubin’s brief involvement and its impact
Rick Rubin’s interest gave the sessions weight. The famed producer invited the band to his home and listened to the new tracks. His presence helped expose the band’s doubts.
The outside opinion served as a prompt. It pushed the group to be honest about the quality of the music. Rather than rush a record, they chose to stop and regroup.
From those failed sessions to the 2013 comeback album
After shelving the 2001 material, Black Sabbath returned to the studio years later and produced 13, released in 2013. That album reunited Ozzy Osbourne, Tony Iommi, and Geezer Butler.
- Bill Ward did not participate in 13, citing contract issues.
- The group opted for a different approach and new production partners.
- 13 became the official next studio chapter after the scrapped material.
The abandoned 2001 recordings became a footnote in the band’s long history. For collectors and fans, traces of that era survive only in live memories and Butler’s remarks.
