Netflix’s The Body disappoints: Catholic schoolgirl horror-drama satire falls flat

Show summary Hide summary

Quinn Shephard’s Netflix series plunges into small-town panic with a devilish spark and early-2000s sheen. Set amid velour tracksuits, flip phones and costume-party excess, the drama tracks a high-school dance team whose initiation ritual detonates paranoia and superstition across their community.

Series snapshot: what to expect from The Body on Netflix

The Body unfolds over roughly eight hours and leans into teen horror and religious panic. Think of it as a mashup of cult-era coming-of-age dread and ritual-driven hysteria. Its mood rarely tilts into outright terror or satire, but it does flirt with provocative excess.

Where the show sits in genre conversation

Plot and setting: 2004 as a character

The action takes place in fall 2004. The era is more than background; it’s a stylistic choice. Costume work and props — from Motorola flip phones to Balenciaga-daydream accessories — make the period tangible. The Lions, a female dance team at St. Marks Catholic High, are the narrative’s eye of the storm.

Close view of 2000s flip phone and retro clothes on chair evoking 2004 setting
Small props and costumes (like flip phones) make the 2004 setting feel specific.

Inciting incident

A Halloween hazing intended as a rite of passage goes catastrophically wrong. A prank, a pill, a joke invoking Satan: small choices accumulate and give rise to strange visions. What starts in a locker room quickly escalates into town-wide dread.

Key characters and performances

The ensemble mixes familiar teen archetypes with a few striking turns. While several roles feel underdeveloped, one presence refuses to be ignored.

  • Grace (Sofia Wylie) — the earnest newcomer whose goodness creates friction with the team.
  • Elise (Sara Boustany) and Anya (Kristina Bogic) — co-captains bound by loyalty and secret struggles with identity.
  • Lisbeth (Geena Meszaros) — the transfer student who becomes the show’s magnetic antagonist.
  • Catherine (Louisa Krause) — Lisbeth’s strict, faith-driven mother.
  • Father Franklin (Nnamdi Asomugha) — the priest whose investigation complicates belief and doubt.
  • Shauna (Gabby Windey) — the dance coach, mostly cameo, who brings oddball charm.

Why Lisbeth dominates the frame

Meszaros crafts a quietly unsettling antagonist. Bleached brows and an off-kilter cadence turn small mannerisms into menace. Even in conversation, Lisbeth’s presence feels like a cold current cutting through the group.

Silhouetted teenager with bleached brows and off-kilter posture suggesting menace
Lisbeth’s look—bleached brows and odd cadence—creates an unsettling presence.

Her performance anchors much of the show’s tension.

Strengths: atmosphere, visual cues, and certain relationships

The production score and wardrobe lean fully into nostalgia. Costume designer Mirren Gordon-Crozier outfits characters in the period’s particular glamour and irony. Some interpersonal dynamics land with genuine power.

  • Elise and Anya’s chemistry creates believable intimacy and conflict.
  • Leo, Lisbeth’s younger brother, offers emotional contrast as a sincere, vulnerable kid.
  • Small casting choices — including Windey’s cameo — add texture to otherwise familiar beats.

Shortcomings: pacing, character depth, and missed ideas

Despite ambition, the series often skims rather than digs. Many characters stay on the surface, serving plot functions more than living as fully realized people. That creates a gap between what the show wants to examine and what it actually explores.

Specific narrative gaps

  • Subplots begin with promise and vanish once their immediate utility ends.
  • Father Franklin’s arc builds tension but rarely probes his faith in a nuanced way.
  • The series gestures at cultural context — reality TV, wartime headlines — without robustly integrating those forces.

Opportunities to push darker or stranger themes are frequently abandoned.

Themes explored: religion, sex, and social spectacle

The Body repeatedly circles questions about belief and desire. It juxtaposes religious iconography with sexualization, often in blunt or performative ways. Costumes like the “slutty angel” become shorthand for a larger conversation the show only hints at.

How the series handles symbolism

  • Religious motifs appear across visuals and narrative beats.
  • Sexual imagery is used to provoke but rarely to interrogate deeply.
  • More daring, subversive links between spirituality and sexuality are suggested but left unexplored.

Direction, tone, and creative fingerprints

Creator Quinn Shephard directs the premiere and steers the series’ tonal experiments. The show is confident in style and uncertain in focus. It often chooses surface shocks over sustained psychological excavation.

  • Directorial flourishes occasionally approach grotesque or satirical territory.
  • The mood remains mostly earnest, resisting full commitment to horror or dark comedy.
  • Production design and music successfully evoke the early aughts.

Who will enjoy The Body — and who might not

Viewers drawn to mood, period detail, and a standout villain will find enough to engage. Those who demand tighter plotting or deeper character studies may feel shortchanged.

  • Recommended for fans of teen supernatural thrillers and nostalgic settings.
  • Less satisfying for audiences seeking rigorous thematic payoff.

Notable creative contributors and cast highlights

The show’s credits include both new faces and familiar performers. Production choices underscore the period and attempt to lend heft to the story’s religious stakes.

  • Creator and director: Quinn Shephard (director of Under the Bridge).
  • Costume designer: Mirren Gordon-Crozier.
  • Standout cast: Geena Meszaros, Sofia Wylie, Sara Boustany, Kristina Bogic, Louisa Krause, Nnamdi Asomugha, Gabby Windey.

Give your feedback

★★★★★

Be the first to rate this post
or leave a detailed review


Post a comment

Publish a comment