Football Manager 26 review: addictive gameplay ruined by ugly visuals

Show summary Hide summary

• Unity engine: a technical leap that shows and hides
• Manager creation reimagined — less number-crunching, more narrative
• Menus and navigation: a modern look that costs depth
• Tactics and Match Day: the gameplay that still captivates
• Women’s football: a long-promised addition
• Practical takeaways: who should dive in now

I’ve spent my life lost in sports management sims, and Football Manager has been the one I keep returning to. FM26 arrives with bold technical changes and clearer match presentation, but its new interface asks veterans to relearn habits. There’s a lot to like beneath the surface — and a lot that will grate on long-time players.

Unity engine: a technical leap that shows and hides

The most obvious change is under the hood: FM26 runs on the Unity engine. That switch explains the two-year gap since FM24 and the cancelled FM25. The payoff is visible in match lighting and camera movement.

Yet not everything benefited equally. Player and manager models still look rough in places. Hair and facial detail feel generic. That distance between expected polish and reality weakens immersion.

• Better lighting and dynamic cameras during matches.
• 3D models improved but still inconsistent in animation and detail.
• Visual upgrades are most obvious in Match Day presentation.

Manager creation reimagined — less number-crunching, more narrative

The new profile system leans into storytelling. Your past career, non-playing roles, and reputation presets now determine core attributes.

This removes manual point allocation and replaces the numeric 1–20 sliders with icons that range from weak to outstanding. That makes it easier to craft a backstory.

“Tendencies” add flavor by shaping personality and tactical leanings. But with that convenience comes reduced flexibility. Veteran players who enjoyed fine-tuning spreadsheets will miss direct control.

Menus and navigation: a modern look that costs depth

The UI adopts a tablet-first aesthetic. Pop-up modules, large spacing, and message-style interactions aim for accessibility. On big monitors, however, the layout feels like wasted space.

Routine tasks now require more clicks. Where once a single click took you from a club to its league table, you might now traverse several nested menus.

• Competition lookup moved behind multiple submenu layers.
• Quick tools like skin reload, cache clear, and attribute-color toggles are harder to find.
• Longstanding visual aids and comparison tools are minimized or relocated.

What used to be immediate is now fragmented. That creates friction for players who enjoyed deep exploration and rapid access to stats.

Tactics and Match Day: the gameplay that still captivates

Despite frustrations with navigation, the tactical side is stronger. The biggest change is split tactics for In- and Out-of-Possession. Roles can now change between phases, producing smarter, more fluid football.

• Assign different roles for attack and defense to the same player.
• Better tactical nuance without excessive complexity.
• Instant Result is now officially supported, speeding up seasons.

Matches look noticeably better. The engine introduces smoother lighting and more natural camera choices. Animations still have clipping and odd collisions, but the presentation is a clear step forward.

The 2D match overlay remains useful for getting a quick tactical read during simmed periods.

Women’s football: a long-promised addition

FM26 includes women’s leagues and squads for the first time. That integration was handled thoughtfully in many ways. Men’s and women’s attributes are treated equally, so a 20 is a 20 across the board.

Both sets of competitions load together in a single save. Female leagues mirror real-world structures: smaller budgets, different transfer patterns, and contract norms that reflect the current game.

• Player databases for women are new and distinct.
• Injury trends and financial realities are modeled differently.
• Some UI and interaction glitches remain unchanged.

Including women’s football is a meaningful step. The implementation still needs polish, but it brings the series closer to a complete simulation of the sport.

Practical takeaways: who should dive in now

FM26 will appeal to players who value match presentation, tactical depth, and the new engine’s polish. If you prioritize in-game visuals and smarter player roles, this edition rewards your time.

However, if you live for fast navigation, data mining, and direct attribute control, the interface changes will feel like obstacles. Many power-user conveniences have been moved or removed.

• Buyers who enjoy tactical experimentation and improved match-feel will be pleased.
• Longtime data-driven players may find the reworked UI frustrating.
• The women’s game inclusion is a strong reason for fresh saves and new projects.

Despite the interface headaches, the engine’s promise and the depth of gameplay under the new skin make FM26 a title that invites both patience and curiosity.